Skip to main content

Why Nuclear is NOT the path forward and why reactors ought to be scrapped


Why Nuclear is NOT the path forward and why reactors ought to be scrapped

Radiation Ghost Towns in Fukushima 


Of course, we've all heard it by now - how nuclear energy was touted as the energy solution to a population of 7 billion, as the panacea to a world overly dependent on harmful fossil fuels, as the revolutionary piece of tech to finally usher us into an energy surplus utopia, as the energy too cheap to meter. For all the exaltation, for all the promise, what has come to be the fate decades later for this proclaimed messiah of mankind? The pro nuclear zealot quickly unleashes the fact in your face that today 10% of humanity’s energy needs are met by nuclear plants at the staggeringly cheap rate of 2 cents a kilowatt-hour. Impressive one may say. Impressive that is if that was all there was to it. Are things in life ever quite that simple?
Any reader with average cerebral equipment must already be mightily uneasy at that curious figure of 2 cents. Similarly curious is the reluctance of the same zealot to a discussion whenever the subject of nuclear waste is broached. Here's what they'll improbably tell you: Firstly, wastes from reactors stay stubbornly radioactive for dozens of millennia posing a grave and permanent hazard to their surroundings. Secondly there are at present only temporary means to contain this nuclear waste at storage facilities which in addition to being obscenely expensive are rapidly running out of space. What happens when we pass that threshold where we are still pumping out nuclear waste but have nowhere to dispose it? Companies are already turning to even more unsafe and more exorbitant options for disposal. At present, methods used to contain radiation from spilling out involve blocking using water aided by a cooler to keep it from evaporating. The inherent and unshakeable risk that emerges with this method is the over reliance on the water not evaporating which in turn is overly reliant on the nuclear reactor staying in perpetual homeostasis. A gamble that history has shown can be lost and to catastrophic consequence. When a tsunami was set off and the fragile homeostasis of the Fukushima reactors was roiled and the water stranding between unsuspecting citizens and catastrophe was stripped…Thirdly, the steel containers which pack these radioactive wastes inside them require a great amount of human monitoring and are always an earthquake or [insert other natural disaster] here away from giving way to your next Fukushima. One would scarcely be off the mark to call these containers as akin to ticking time bombs except deadlier. Much, much deadlier. The subject of cancer risk is another to be conspicuously avoided. The horror of Chernobyl wasn't the death toll of 31 on that day. The horror of Chernobyl was the radiation induced cancer that later claimed 4000 unsuspecting lives. Both Chernobyl and Fukushima became virtually uninhabitable following their respective disasters displacing hundreds of thousands. A test of urine samples from 1500 preschool kids in Fukushima revealed Caesium traces in 104. More recently and quite alarmingly, a 2018 report by Fukushima University found the disaster site was still leaking contaminated water into the Pacific at 2GBq/day and Greenpeace detected multiple radiation hotspots in dangerous proximity to selected sports venues at Fukushima for the upcoming Olympics in Japan.



What is the cost borne by that child with Caesium in his urine? What is the cost borne by the increasingly polluted pacific and its marine life? What is the cost borne by unsuspecting citizens with nuclear waste in their backyard? What is the cost borne by the hundreds of thousands displaced? What will be the cost borne by posterity who will live side by side with the wastes we leave behind? What is the cost of nuclear technology inevitably winding up in wrong hands and giving way to more weapons of mass destruction? What is the cost of ignorance? Two cents a kilowatt-hour or… Have we finally begun to account for the nuclear cost of nuclear?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

A deep-dive into Get Out: A series in five parts - Quintet Part 5 - The metaphor everyone missed

A deep-dive into Get Out: A series in five parts - Quintet Part 5 - The metaphor everyone missed I still distinctly remember my first viewing of Get Out and how I vacillated and contemplated in the hours that followed in my hostel room and later at the canteen upstairs, trying to peer deeper into the film's message. I just couldn't settle down until I felt like I had nailed it down. Due to an unknown why, the film had strangely struck a chord with my own life experience and this was still so without me ever having been black or in a room full of white people. Of course, as I've already pointed out I vicariously experienced those through the film and it constitutes a significant part of the reason why I appreciate the film as much as I do and why I've rewatched it as many times as I have. But even beyond that there was something about the film - more precisely the Coagula transplantation and hypnosis procedure - that spoke directly to my own experience and not...

A deep-dive into Get Out: A series in five parts - Quintet Part 4 - Uncanny Parallels

A deep-dive into Get Out : A series in five parts - Quintet Part 4 - Uncanny Parallels Then on a dimension above the ones I have discussed in the preceding three parts are scenes the viewer will need a keen eye and a well-informed mind to be able to pick apart and extract the profound kernels of truth and brilliant parallels to real-life social phenomena. To me they make for the most mind-splattering parts of the movie and qualify it as ingenious. I’ll list some of my favourites in this category too as I simply love talking about this movie and would love for more people to develop an appreciation for what makes this movie so wonderful. The movie reflects heavily on the precarious and eerie race relations and dynamics in contemporary America, in particular the experience and plight of African Americans. One theme Peele draws constant attention to is that of being the lone person of color or being a minority in a white dominated and white majority space. The viewer gets to ...